Suicide Incident Shocks Monks St. Anthony Monastery in Arizona

A 27-year-old young monk committed suicide at the at St. Anthony monastery in Arizona, according to a National Herald report. He had been in the community for six years prior to his death.

The suicide was made known on Monomakhos by Ashley Nevins the victim’s father.
The Orthodox monk’s civilian name was Scott Nevin and he was American from Modesto, California.

It appears that the 27-year-old had some sort of hatred against Ephraim, the igoumen or abbot of the monastery. He had published the following post,“We are here simply to expose St. Anthony’s Greek Orthodox Monastery as a cult, and to expose Elder Ephraim as a cult leader . . .I (Scott Nevins) was a novice at St. Anthony’s monastery for six years and saw Elder Ephraim, the charlatan, on a daily basis. I am convinced, based on my experience, that the Elder is a cult leader, and the monastery is a cult,” at http://www.elderephraimscult.com, a website he founded.

The information so far is rather obscure. It is only certain that he had fled the monastery 15 months ago, unable to endure the monastic suppression and deprivation. He returned to the monastery last Sunday armed with two guns and a knife, having previously visited Oregon.

, ,



  • Rexorum

    Ephraimites call Elder Ephraim as a living saint but has this ever happened to a saint before in the history of the Church??!?

  • Marina

    I respect the monastery but I don’t agree with some people calling him a living saint. There is no such thing in Orthodoxy because he is still living. There are people who treat him like a cult leader but that’s their ignorance. He never said he’s a saint. It’s also how people have reacted to their monastic life there with such traditional Orthodoxy. With American life style here in a country that’s not much more than 200 years old culture clashes with a tradition over 2,000 years old.

    • Maria

      Does he do anything to discourage the cultists from flocking around their monasteries? The monastics not only seem to enjoy having these type of people around, but they also encourage it. If you do not act like you “worship” the elder (and even his monastics) then you are an outsider and they make this very obvious to you. You are “punished” somewhat and not treated nearly as well as those who call the elder sinless, saint, perfect, etc. the monasteries could be so much better if they did not do this and they could actually help everyone, the cultists and those in need of spiritual help.